The fused pass stops at "linear working values" when a sharpener, a
blur or a repair follows, and the detail passes convolve what it hands
on. Until now it handed on the rendering: the base curve, and since the
last commit the view transform, ran before the store. So every kernel
worked on display-referred values while its comments promised the
opposite — D19's second finding.
A fused pass composed for a detail stage now stops before the view
transform, and carries a second shader, `ComposedShader::view`, composed
from the same inputs. It runs the same prologue, for the positions a
fragment reads (a film's grain seeds from `source_px`) and the corners
it blacks out, takes its colour from the detail stage's result bound
where the sample cache would be, and runs the view transform, the
output transform and the mask reveal. `render_detailed` dispatches it
after the last detail pass, in the same encoder.
So no detail pass encodes any more. Every pass writes an intermediate,
the last one included, which retires three things that existed only to
make the last pass encode: `writes_output` and the runner's second
layout, the body-less resolve pass for an active kernel with nothing to
draw at this scale, and capture sharpening's pass-through, which now
emits no pass at all. An empty chain is a whole render: the view pass
reads the fused result directly. The detail stage no longer takes an
output space either, so `compose_detail_for` folds into
`compose_detail` and the space is named once, on the fused half.
The cost is one full-render read and write per frame when a detail
stage exists, and a third intermediate for a one-pass chain.
Capture sharpening at a scale too coarse to draw its radius emits one pass
with an empty body (`nothing_to_sharpen`), so that a chain still ends in
something that performs the output transform. At fit on any modern sensor
that is most of the time. When another neighbourhood operation follows it
- dehaze, clarity, texture - the pass is not last and does nothing: it
reads the rgba16float intermediate and writes the same texels to the other
one. It still cost a full render-sized read and write every frame:
scene before after
sharpen+clarity 2560x1600 fit 18.66 ms 14.16 ms
sharpen+clarity 3840x2160 fit 37.93 ms 27.88 ms
every operation 2560x1600 fit 71.80 ms 67.24 ms
clarity alone 2560x1600 fit 14.23 ms 14.20 ms (control)
sharpen+clarity 2560x1600 1:1 23.01 ms 22.97 ms (control: resolves)
(Laptop RTX 3050 held at 420/810 MHz by its power cap, synthetic 60 MP
source, median of five alternated runs of forty frames each.)
`compose_detail_with` now drops such a pass where dropping it is exact:
not the last pass, whose output transform would otherwise move onto the
previous pass's f32 result and round differently; and not a pass right
after a reduced one, because a full-resolution pass is what closes the
reduced chain for the operation after it. `DetailPass::is_identity` says
what "changes nothing" means: full size, nothing bound at binding 3, and a
body with no code in it.
The rgba8 output is bit-identical: every scene above hashed the same
before and after, and the sharpen+clarity frame hashes the same as clarity
on its own, which is the claim in one line. A new dr-pipeline test pins
the three cases - dropped ahead of another operation, kept when last, kept
when alone.
docs/ had 26 developer documents flat beside the manual, and the two
audiences are very differently sized: most readers want the manual and
the gesture reference, a few want the register, the designs and the
measurements. The manual and gestures.md stay at the top; everything for
someone changing the code moves to docs/dev/, and the two documents that
name their own successors — the v0.1 milestone and the UI-refinement plan
— go to docs/dev/archive/ rather than being deleted, since both are still
cited. docs/README.md is the index, users first.
Every reference follows: code comments, Cargo manifests, the workflows,
the pre-commit hook, the bench and traceability tools (which locate the
repo root by docs/dev/requirements.md now), packaging, the Docker READMEs,
CLAUDE.md, CONTRIBUTING.md and the README. The matrix links one level
deeper and is regenerated. Links out of the moved documents into the tree
gain a level; a link checker over every Markdown file finds none broken.
`lens.rs` has held a `Warp` trait, a composer and two implementations —
distortion and lateral chromatic aberration — since they were written, and
`compose_warps` was called by nothing outside its own tests. The corrections
existed, were correct, and never touched a photograph.
`EditGraph` now holds them, and `compose_full` emits them between the framing
prologue and the fetch. Distortion first, then CA: each warp receives the
position the previous one produced, and lateral CA is a magnification about
the optical axis of the *undistorted* frame, so measured on a barrel-distorted
one it would be fitted to a radius no profile describes.
They reach the panel the way framing already does — through `capabilities`.
That was the one open question and existing practice answered it: framing is
also not an `Operation`, also has parameters a photographer sets, and also
arrives through that list. Because `Preset::capture` walks the same list, the
sidecar, the clipboard and the undo stack carry a warp's parameters with
nothing registered anywhere, and no file under `ui/` names one (FR-DEV-3a).
`state()` destructures `EditGraph` field by field precisely so that a new
field cannot be forgotten, and it was not.
Chromatic aberration is the only thing that samples per channel, and
`splits_channels` is what keeps everything else from paying for it. Red and
blue are fetched from positions green is not — green is the reference and
never moves, so a wrong correction still leaves one channel sharp rather than
softening all three. With no CA in the chain the single-fetch path is emitted
instead.
The interpolating sampler is now chosen by framing *or* an active warp. Asking
framing alone would have nearest-neighboured a distortion correction on an
unstraightened frame, and that aliasing reads as a bad profile rather than as
a missing filter.
The warps go in the geometry invalidation key rather than the colour one: they
decide which source pixel a colour is read from, so a tile cached across a
distortion change would keep drawing the previous correction. The pipeline
cache needs nothing new — `hash_source` already covers the generated body, and
uniform values never enter it, so arming a warp recompiles and dragging it
does not. Both are asserted.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Clarity's Gaussian sigma is 1.2% of the frame's shorter edge, so its radius
is a property of the viewport: 52 render pixels at 4K, two separable passes
of 105 taps each over 8.3 M pixels. That measured 33.9 ms — seven times the
entire fused point chain, for one slider — and is docs/technical-debt.md TD-4.
A detail pass may now declare `output_scale`, and clarity's base is computed
on a grid a quarter the size on each axis.
The pass that combines needs the blur *and* the full-resolution colour, and a
colour that has been through a quarter-scale target is no longer full
resolution. So a scaled pass cannot simply join the ping-pong: there are two
chains now. The full-resolution one carries the colour and no scaled pass
touches it; the reduced one carries the base and reaches the combining pass
through a second binding as `reduced_at()`.
The reduce is a dispatch of its own rather than something the first blur half
does on the way past, and that is the whole difference between this and the
strided kernel the module documentation rules out. A stride samples an image
that is not band-limited and aliases high-frequency content down into the
base, which is then subtracted, and arrives in the output as mottling across
smooth gradients. This band-limits first and samples after. What is discarded
is content the base could not represent at any resolution, because a Gaussian
at sigma = 26 px holds nothing above one cycle per 26 px and the quarter-scale
grid carries one per 8 — so the reduced base is not an approximation of the
full-resolution one, it is the same function sampled where it is still
determined.
Which is also why the scale belongs to the band rather than to the stage.
Texture's sigma is a decade finer, so the reduce pass's own box would be wider
than the Gaussian it was prefiltering; texture never reduces. And clarity
steps 4 -> 2 -> 1 as sigma falls, because a quarter of a small sigma is not a
Gaussian either — the case that gives up is the one that was already cheap.
`radius` stays in each pass's own pixels and `ComposedDetail::radius` multiplies
it back up, so 13 reduced pixels at scale 4 still report the 52 render pixels a
tile would have to be grown by. The halo a scheduler sees does not move.
The halo tests pass unchanged, which was TD-4's stated bar; they render at
1024 px and so exercise the reduced path rather than stepping around it. Added
`crossing_the_reduction_threshold_does_not_change_the_picture`, because
nothing yet compared the reduced form against a *less* reduced one — every
other test measures one form against itself. It renders the same edit either
side of the 4 -> 2 step-down and holds the peak excursion to 0.03 stops and
the reach to 2% of the frame.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
`Operation::descriptor()` returned `&'static OpDescriptor`, and that lifetime
is the whole reason a build-time node is free and a run-time node is
impossible: only a compile-time literal can satisfy it, so no amount of
reading `ops/*.yaml` at startup could ever produce a descriptor the rest of
the application would accept. FR-PLG-2 says a bundled operation and a
third-party plugin are the same kind of thing, differing only in where the
file was found — and a lifetime outsiders cannot meet is exactly the second,
weaker format that requirement forbids.
So a descriptor is now owned and handed out as `Arc<OpDescriptor>`, with `Vec`
where it held `&'static` slices. `Arc` rather than a `&self`-borrowed
reference because the callers want to *keep* it: the develop panel collects
descriptors and then mutates the graph, and a borrow would tie the
descriptor's lifetime to a borrow of the operation it came from, which is the
one thing `&'static` was doing right.
The identifier newtypes deliberately did not follow. `ParamId` is `Copy`, is
compared in `match` arms against generated constants, is a map key in the
sidecar and history, and reaches Slint model rows; an `Arc<str>` there would
cost a refcount on every one of those and would take `match id { EXPOSURE =>
.. }` away from the generated code. They gain an interner instead, which is
honest about its lifetime rather than pretending to one — the set of ids is
bounded by deduplication and is process-lifetime by construction, because the
sidecar on disk names its parameters and an id has to stay resolvable for as
long as any edit naming it can be opened.
No behaviour changes. Every descriptor that was a `static` is a `LazyLock`
initialiser now, `Operation::helpers` borrows from `self` instead of being
`'static` so a future run-time node can own its list, and `Warp` and `Framing`
follow `Operation` so there is one shape rather than two.
The one place a descriptor is read per frame is `compose_full`, which takes
`descriptor().id` to prefix each active operation's uniforms, and `dr-ui`
composes on every frame it draws. That is a dozen atomic increments beside a
composition that is already building several kilobytes of WGSL on the same
call; it is noted at the trait method rather than left for a profiler to find.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
A spot set now composes detail passes of its own, one per round, and they
go ahead of every operation's kernel. That placement is the decision worth
recording: a sharpening pass reads a neighbourhood, so sharpening a dust
mark before removing it smears its edge into pixels the repair's disc does
not cover, and what survives is a faint over-sharpened ring around an
otherwise perfect patch. It also disagrees with ARCH §5.2, which draws
spot removal after clarity — docs/spot-removal.md §5.1 is where that is
argued out.
Every length reaching the shader is in render pixels, converted here where
the framing is in scope. Both the centre and the source go through
`Framing::output_at` — the same map the fused pass applies to every pixel
— so a rotated photograph rotates the offset with no trigonometry, and the
radius is found by mapping a point one radius above the centre and
measuring, rather than by multiplying by a ratio this function has no
business knowing about. The tests turn and crop the frame and expect the
mark to stay gone, which is the property that arrangement buys.
compose_full now takes the spot set, because a photograph with a repair
and no sharpening still has a detail stage: a fused pass that encoded its
own output there would quantise twice and bind to a texture of the wrong
format. compose_detail_for takes the source size for the same kind of
reason — a RenderScale describes the region on screen, and a spot is
stored against the photograph.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Every neighbourhood pass so far has been a convolution, whose whole
description fits in the uniform block because its structure fixes how many
numbers it needs. Spot removal is not that shape: sixty-four repairs and
one repair are the same shader with a different buffer behind it.
So a pass may declare `storage`, which arrives at binding 3 as
`array<vec4<f32>>` with `arrayLength` in scope. The alternative — packing
the list into uniforms — needs a fixed maximum paid for on every frame, a
composer that can emit vec4 fields because a uniform array's stride is 16
whatever it holds, and it gives the next operation that wants a table
nothing to build on.
The property worth having is what stays out of the generated source: the
count is in the buffer, so placing the tenth spot uploads 512 bytes and
reuses the compiled pipeline, exactly as moving a slider does for the
fused pass. `changing_the_list_does_not_recompile` is that, asserted.
One bind group entry rather than two more layouts, and one placeholder
buffer allocated in `new` rather than sixteen bytes per pass per frame —
a zero-length storage buffer cannot be bound, and per-frame allocation is
what this module's documentation exists to refuse.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
`cargo fmt --check` is a required step and had drifted across 45 files. Most of
it arrived this week: several operations were written in parallel worktrees and
merged by hand, and a hand-merge resolves conflicts without ever running the
formatter over the result.
No behaviour changes — this is `cargo fmt --all` and nothing else, kept as its
own commit so the next reader can skip it wholesale rather than search it for
one that matters.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
An active detail operation may emit no pass at a given render scale - the
honest answer for a sensor-sized radius on a heavy proxy. The fused composer
cannot see that, having no resolution to consult, so it had already stopped
short of the output transform and the frame died on a storage-format
mismatch. Compose a bodyless resolve pass in that case so the output
transform still happens exactly once.
Checkpoint committed by the coordinator, not by the authoring agent: the
session hit its API limit mid-task and left this work uncommitted. Committed
so it survives, NOT because it is finished - expect failing tests and
half-applied changes. The agent resumes from here.
The fused pass hands a fragment a colour and no coordinate. That is what buys
one dispatch for a whole edit, and it is also a wall: sharpening, noise
reduction, clarity, texture, dehaze and spot removal are each defined by what
the neighbours are doing, and FR-DEV-3 and FR-DEV-8 ask for all six. None of
them could be written at any price.
So there is now a detail stage. An operation implements `Operation` for its
parameters exactly as before — the panel, the sidecar, the history and the
presets all work unchanged — and additionally returns `Affects::Detail` and a
`DetailStage` yielding one pass per dispatch. `Affects` grows the third variant
`docs/requirements.md:250` designed and nothing had cut.
Where the stage sits is a colour-science decision, not an arrangement of
convenience. It runs after every point operation and every mask layer, so an
amount chosen against a tone curve survives the curve moving; in linear sRGB
after the camera matrix, because camera RGB has no luminance to sharpen
against; and before the output transform and the clip, because FR-DEV-2 allows
one quantisation and a highlight clipped before a convolution grows a dark
ring. The fused pass therefore ends one of two ways, and when a detail stage
follows it hands on unclipped f16 and the last detail pass encodes.
At render resolution rather than on the source, which is the whole of FR-DSP-1:
a pass before the framing prologue would cost 24 MP to draw a 2 MP preview.
`RenderScale` is what makes that survivable — a radius is stored as a fraction
of the frame's shorter edge, exactly as a mask feather already is, or as a
count of source pixels, and converted per render. It also reports when a radius
is smaller than a proxy pixel rather than drawing a plausible lie; zooming to
1:1 makes the preview exact with no second path.
`Invalidation` gives FR-DEV-3d something to mean. Moving a detail parameter
leaves the colour key alone, so `AdjustPass` keeps the linear intermediate and
skips the fused dispatch: dragging a sharpening slider costs a convolution.
Moving exposure does re-run the detail passes, because they read what the
colour pass wrote, and there is no arrangement of keys that avoids it while
keeping sharpening after tone.
Validated by a separable box blur that is not a develop operation, behind the
`detail-probe` feature and absent from a shipping build. An abstraction with no
consumer is a guess; a box blur's answer is known in closed form, so the tests
assert every byte of the ramp rather than that the edge got softer.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
dtourolle
