FR-UI-1 — The layout table puts tablet portrait in the compact class, and neither decision agrees #54

New Issue

2026-09-06T08:11:12Z

dtourolle commented

2026-09-06 08:11:12 +00:00

FR-UI-1's table puts tablet portrait in the compact class, and no decision since agrees with it.

The register (docs/requirements.md §FR-UI-1) reads:

Class	Typical	Develop layout
Compact	Tablet portrait, narrow desktop window	Canvas full-width; one collapsible panel at a time; filmstrip on demand
Expanded	Tablet landscape, desktop	Filmstrip, canvas, and adjustment panel simultaneously

D-N2 (docs/ui-navigation.md) established that both orientations of the tablet clear EXPANDED_MIN_WIDTH and are expanded. D-N7 then adds an axis the table has no column for: on a tall window the column docks under the photograph, independent of class.

Deliverable

Amend FR-UI-1 so the register says what the code does:

Tablet portrait moves to the expanded row.
A sentence records that the develop column's side — beside or below the canvas — follows the window's aspect and is independent of the class, citing D-N7.
The "transition is continuous rather than a mode switch" clause stays; the dock is a placement, not a mode.

docs/traceability.md regenerates in the same commit (the pre-commit hook does it).

Acceptance

FR-UI-1 names the aspect axis and cites D-N7
Tablet portrait is no longer listed as compact
The traceability matrix is regenerated in the same commit

**FR-UI-1's table puts tablet portrait in the compact class, and no decision since agrees with it.** The register (`docs/requirements.md` §FR-UI-1) reads: | Class | Typical | Develop layout | |---|---|---| | Compact | Tablet portrait, narrow desktop window | Canvas full-width; one collapsible panel at a time; filmstrip on demand | | Expanded | Tablet landscape, desktop | Filmstrip, canvas, and adjustment panel simultaneously | D-N2 (`docs/ui-navigation.md`) established that both orientations of the tablet clear `EXPANDED_MIN_WIDTH` and are expanded. D-N7 then adds an axis the table has no column for: on a tall window the column docks under the photograph, independent of class. ## Deliverable Amend FR-UI-1 so the register says what the code does: - Tablet portrait moves to the expanded row. - A sentence records that the develop column's side — beside or below the canvas — follows the window's aspect and is independent of the class, citing D-N7. - The "transition is continuous rather than a mode switch" clause stays; the dock is a placement, not a mode. `docs/traceability.md` regenerates in the same commit (the pre-commit hook does it). ## Acceptance - [ ] FR-UI-1 names the aspect axis and cites D-N7 - [ ] Tablet portrait is no longer listed as compact - [ ] The traceability matrix is regenerated in the same commit

dtourolle added the size:S decision docs labels 2026-09-06 08:11:12 +00:00

dtourolle commented

2026-09-06 22:22:21 +00:00

Amended on branch docs/fr-ui-1-portrait (commit d91f468), merged into integrate/portrait-dock. Tablet portrait moved to the expanded row; the aspect axis is recorded citing D-N7; FR-UI-2 gains the D-N6 clause. Traceability unchanged.

Amended on branch `docs/fr-ui-1-portrait` (commit d91f468), merged into `integrate/portrait-dock`. Tablet portrait moved to the expanded row; the aspect axis is recorded citing D-N7; FR-UI-2 gains the D-N6 clause. Traceability unchanged.

dtourolle commented

2026-09-11 21:54:24 +00:00

Landed in 2361b2d. Tablet portrait is in the expanded row, the develop column's side is recorded as a placement following the window's aspect and independent of the class, citing D-N7, and the continuous-transition clause stands. The traceability matrix has been regenerated since and is consistent with the tree.

Landed in 2361b2d. Tablet portrait is in the expanded row, the develop column's side is recorded as a placement following the window's aspect and independent of the class, citing D-N7, and the continuous-transition clause stands. The traceability matrix has been regenerated since and is consistent with the tree.

dtourolle closed this issue

2026-09-11 21:54:25 +00:00

Sign in to join this conversation.

1 Participants

Notifications

Due Date

No due date set.

Dependencies

No dependencies set.

Reference: dtourolle/DarkRoom#54