FR-EXP-1 listed four things in one sentence: JPEG, PNG, TIFF at both depths,
and AVIF or JPEG XL. Three of them are built, encode, embed an ICC profile, and
are covered by tests that walk every offered format. The fourth is a deliberate
deferral — `export` returns `FormatUnsupported` for AVIF and JPEG XL, and
`the_formats_without_an_encoder_say_so` pins that behaviour in place.
Fused, the requirement could only be tagged dishonestly or not at all, and not
at all is worse: it would delete the register's record of the part that is
finished, which is most of it.
So the v1 scope is now JPEG, PNG and TIFF with the configurability clause, and
AVIF and JPEG XL are stated as post-v1 with the condition that already holds —
either may appear in the settings page before its encoder does, provided
choosing it fails with a typed error naming the format rather than producing a
file. That is what `every_offered_format_either_encodes_or_explains_itself`
exists to guarantee, and it is why a format cannot be added to the picker and
quietly reach an encoder that does not handle it.
No intent is dropped. AVIF and JPEG XL remain wanted; they are now scheduled
rather than silently outstanding.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
dtourolleandClaude Opus 5
8865743db6