DarkRoom/core/dr-pipeline/ops/README.md

# Develop nodes

One file per operation. Adding a node to the pipeline is adding a file to this
directory — there is no list to extend, no shader to edit, and no UI change.

`../build.rs` compiles each declaration into Rust implementing
[`Operation`](../src/operation.rs), generated into `OUT_DIR`. The result is
indistinguishable downstream from a hand-written operation: the same
`&'static OpDescriptor`, the same fused-shader composition, the same sidecar
round-trip.

## `attributes:` — what the operation is about

Required, one or more of `tone`, `colour`, `detail`, `optics`, `geometry`,
`effect`. The build fails without it, and that is deliberate: an operation with
no attribute is invisible to an interface that groups by them, and a control
that silently does not exist is a worse failure than a build that stops.

**Say what the operation is, not where you want it drawn.** The core declares
capabilities; the frontend composes (ARCH §4.3a). `tone` means "this is about
lightness", not "put this in the second tab" — the interface is free to render
attributes as tabs, as headings, or not at all, and that choice may differ
between a tablet and a desktop without this file changing.

**Plural is normal.** The tone curve is `[tone, colour]` because an RGB curve
is tonal and the per-channel curves are chromatic; it appears wherever the
frontend decides that means. Reach for a second attribute when an operation
genuinely answers two questions, not to make it easier to find.

**The vocabulary is closed.** A typo is a build error rather than a new
category containing exactly one operation — which looks identical to a
deliberate new category until somebody notices the group with one control in
it.

## What you get for free

A node dropped in here arrives with:

- **Controls.** The develop panel builds them from the parameters' declared
  kinds (FR-DEV-3c). It never learns the node's name.
- **A place in the chain**, from `order:`.
- **A place in the panel**, from `attributes:`. The interface groups by these
  and names no operation, so a node arrives in the right group by saying what
  it is rather than by anyone editing a list in `ui/`.
- **Persistence.** Parameters are ordinary scalars, so the sidecar writes them
  with everything else.
- **Its tests**, compiled from `tests:` and run with `cargo test`.
- **Neutral-means-absent.** At its defaults the node contributes no code, no
  uniform, and no branch to the generated shader.

## The shape of a file

```yaml
id: exposure                 # must match the filename
label: op.exposure           # a localisation key, never a display string
order: 20                    # where it sits in the chain
attributes: [tone]           # what it is about; one or more, and required

doc: |                       # becomes the generated module's documentation
  Exposure — a linear gain, expressed in stops.
placement: |                 # why it sits where it does; appears above the
  A correction to capture.   # entry in the generated chain

params:
  exposure:
    label: param.exposure
    kind: stops
    min: -5
    max: 5
    doc: |                   # optional prose, kept with the descriptor
      ±5 stops.

uniforms:
  gain: exp2(exposure)       # shorthand, or a mapping with `value:` and `doc:`

helpers: [luminance]         # names from _helpers.yaml
define:                      # helpers this node alone needs
  my_curve: |
    fn my_curve(x: f32) -> f32 { return x; }

wgsl: |                      # `c` is linear RGB in and out
  c = c * gain;

presentation:                # optional; omit for one control per parameter
  widgets: [tone_curve]      # a hint, most preferred first
  params: [exposure]         # what that widget owns

tests:
  - name: one_stop_is_a_doubling
    why: The definition of a stop.
    set: { exposure: 1 }
    expect: { gain: 2.0 }
```

### Parameter kinds

| `kind` | Shape | Extra keys |
|---|---|---|
| `amount` | −100…100, neutral at 0 — the familiar photographic control | — |
| `stops` | exposure-like, in stops | `min`, `max` |
| `fraction` | 0…1 | `default` |
| `switch` | a toggle, neutral off | — |
| `enum` | one of a short, fixed list | `variants` |
| `scalar` | anything else | `min`, `max`, `default`, `unit`, `scale`, `precision` |

Reach for `amount` first. Writing its range out by hand in each node is how one
of them comes to disagree with the rest.

An `enum` names its choices as localisation keys, most-neutral first:

```yaml
params:
  method:
    label: param.method
    kind: enum
    variants: [param.method.fast, param.method.exact]
```

The value is the chosen **index**, carried as an `f32` like every other
parameter — so a uniform expression can use it (`method` is 0 or 1), the
sidecar stores it unchanged, and nothing along the way needed a second kind of
value. The default is always the first variant, so `reset` means what it means
everywhere else; if your neutral choice is not first, reorder the list rather
than reaching for a `default:`.

Two variants is the minimum. A one-entry list is a control the user cannot
change, and the build rejects it.

### Uniform expressions

Arithmetic (`+ - * /`), parentheses, numbers, this node's parameters, and:
`exp2` `log2` `exp` `sqrt` `abs` `floor` `ceil` `round` `pow` `min` `max`
`clamp` `mix`.

Compiled to Rust, so an unknown name or a wrong arity is a build error naming
the file and the key. Deliberately small: a node is a description, and letting
it name arbitrary Rust would make this a second, worse place to write code.

### Activity

By default a node is active exactly when some parameter has moved off its
default, which is the honest rule and the right one for nearly everything. A
node whose neutral is something else declares `active:` as an expression —
non-zero means active.

### Presentation

Optional, and absent from nearly every node: one control per parameter is the
right answer for a list of unrelated sliders, which is what most operations
are. Declare it when several parameters form **one** conceptual control.

```yaml
presentation:
  widgets: [colour_wheel]        # most preferred first
  demand:
    two_dimensional: true        # dragged in x and y at once
    precise_pointing: false      # needs accuracy finer than a fingertip
  params: [hue, strength]        # what the widget owns, in its order
```

Widgets: `tone_curve`, `colour_wheel`, `crop_overlay`, `gradient_handle`,
`brush_mask`, `white_point`.

**It is a hint and only a hint.** The frontend walks `widgets` and takes the
first it both implements and can afford; if it implements none of them, or
cannot meet the `demand`, it renders the parameters as ordinary sliders and the
edit still works. So it is safe to name a widget nothing draws yet — the node
degrades to sliders rather than breaking. That fallback is also why every
parameter must stay an ordinary scalar: it is what there is to fall back *to*.

`demand` says what the widget inherently needs, never what the screen has.
There is deliberately no way to write a pixel width, a breakpoint or a platform
name here — those are the frontend's to decide, and a node that reasoned about
them would eventually be wrong about a display it never saw (ARCH §4.3a).

Parameters named in `params:` are claimed by the widget and not drawn
separately, so a typo would take a parameter out of both. The build checks each
name against the node's own `params:` and fails if it does not match.

### Tests

| Key | Asserts |
|---|---|
| `set` | parameter values to apply first; build fails if out of range |
| `expect` | uniform values, within 1e-5 |
| `expect_range` | a uniform lies in `[low, high]` |
| `expect_active` | whether the node reaches the shader |
| `expect_wgsl` | substrings the fragment must contain |
| `expect_helper_wgsl` | substrings a named helper must contain |

`why:` becomes a comment in the generated test. Use it — a test named for a
property should say what breaks without it.

## Hand-written nodes

Some operations are not four facts, and forcing them into this schema would
produce a worse language aimed at one caller. Those stay in
[`../src/ops/`](../src/ops/) and declare only their position here:

```yaml
id: tone_curve
order: 60
rust: ToneCurve
why_rust: |
  Its neutral is a relationship between five points, not a set of values.
```

They still belong in this directory, because the pipeline's **order** is the
one thing a reader comes here to learn, and an order written half in YAML and
half in Rust would be worse than either alone.

Currently hand-written: `tone_curve` (a curve widget over five interpolated
points), `colour_mixer` (thirty-six faceted parameters from twelve computed hue
bands), `capture_sharpen` (a separable convolution, which is the other reason a
node is Rust — see the next section). `vignetting` is hand-written too but is
not in the develop chain — it
carries lens-profile coefficients that are not parameters. `distortion` and
`aberration` are `Warp`s rather than operations: they rewrite coordinates
before sampling rather than transforming a colour after it.

## Nodes that read their neighbours

`wgsl:` above is handed `c`, a colour, and no coordinate. That is what makes
the fused dispatch possible and it is also a wall: sharpening, noise reduction,
clarity, texture, dehaze and spot removal are all defined by what the
*neighbouring* pixels are doing, and none of them can be written as a function
of `c` at any price.

They go in the **detail stage**, which runs after the fused pass, in linear
light, at render resolution, before the output transform — see
[`../src/detail.rs`](../src/detail.rs) for why each of those is a decision
rather than a convenience. A node of this kind:

- is declared here with `rust:`, like any other hand-written node, because a
  kernel is not four facts and stretching this schema to cover one would
  produce a worse language than Rust;
- implements `Operation` as usual — descriptor, parameters, `is_active` — so
  the panel, the sidecar, the history and the presets all work unchanged;
- returns `Affects::Detail` from `affects()` and `Some(self)` from `detail()`;
- implements `DetailStage::passes`, returning one `DetailPass` per dispatch,
  each with a WGSL body, its uniforms, and **its kernel radius in render
  pixels**, which the tile scheduler needs and nothing can infer.

`capture_sharpen` is the worked example: two passes, one per axis, and a radius
converted from source pixels once per render.

The `order:` still belongs here, and still orders the node — among the other
detail nodes. Detail runs as a group after every point operation, so an `order:`
that interleaves one with exposure would be a lie the chain cannot tell.

The one thing to get right is the **unit of a radius**. Never store pixels: a
length is either a fraction of the frame's shorter edge (`RenderScale::
frame_fraction` — clarity, texture, the unit a mask feather already uses) or a
count of source pixels (`RenderScale::source_pixels` — capture sharpening,
luminance NR). `passes()` is given the scale and converts on the CPU. A radius
in raw pixels is a different photograph on screen and in the exported file.

## What is not a node, and why

Three things act on every pixel and are deliberately not in this directory:
the as-shot white balance, the camera matrix, and the **base curve**
(FR-DEV-3e). They are emitted by [`../src/operation.rs`](../src/operation.rs)
into the composed shader's fixed preamble, around the block of nodes.

The test is not "does it transform a colour" — all three do. It is **whose
decision is it**. A node is something a photographer chose: it has parameters,
it moves off a neutral, it lands in the sidecar, it can be undone. These three
are properties of the *file*, at the same standing as the masked-photosite crop
(FR-RAW-3) and the stored orientation (FR-DEV-3h). Nobody chose the sensor's
green sensitivity or the body's rendering; they are what reading the file
correctly means.

Making the base curve a node would have said the opposite in four places at
once. It would have appeared in the develop panel as a control, so an
unprofiled body would show a slider that does nothing. Its values would have
gone into the sidecar, and sidecars are shared between devices and bodies
(FR-NC-9) — one camera's rendering would follow an edit onto another camera's
file. Its neutral would have had to be "the identity", so a profiled body would
open reporting itself modified. And there is no seam through which a node could
learn which camera took the frame: the profile arrives on the decoded image,
travels through `DemosaicedImage` beside the matrix it belongs with, and is
written into the uniform block by the same three lines in `dr-gpu` — which is
exactly the path the matrix already took, because it is exactly the same kind
of thing.

What it *does* share with the tone curve node is the spline. The composer asks
`ToneCurve` for its `curve_span`/`curve_eval` helpers rather than emitting a
second copy, so a profile author placing a control point and a photographer
dragging one mean the same thing by it.

The order still reads correctly from this directory: the base curve runs after
every node in the chain and before the conversion out of camera space. That is
the same reasoning `exposure` records under `placement:` — corrections to
capture are only meaningful on linear values, so the rendering goes last.

## Errors

The build script reports failures by naming the key you got wrong, and exits
rather than panicking, so the message is the message and not a backtrace. It
refuses: a duplicate `order:`, a filename disagreeing with its `id:`, a default
outside its own range, a test value the graph would clamp before the node saw
it, a helper that does not define the function it names, an expression naming
something that is not a parameter, and a declared node whose name collides with
a file in `../src/ops/`.